Skip to Content

6 Best CarMax Alternatives for Selling Your Car! [2024]

6 Best CarMax Alternatives for Selling Your Car! [2024]

CarMax Alternatives: Cars and cars. 85% out of 100 people are said to be car enthusiasts. And being a car enthusiast grabs your attention more on cars and everything related to the automotive industry. 

Be it renting a car, selling a car, or buying a car, while doing any of it, we need security and the surety of the perfect ride. Even non-car enthusiasts need the best car for a great deal because no one can go wrong with cars. 

In today’s world, no one runs behind offline stores and garages to find a perfect ride, everything and anything can just be done with a few clicks and taps. So apps coming from the automotive industry are growing at a great pace which offers hassle-free processes. 

Today the apps help us connect with buyers and sellers online with all the car details and great prices to offer. You can easily book a test drive online just within five minutes of research. 

CarMax is a very popular automotive industry app that has gained massive popularity for online services related to cars. CarMax is known for many features like car delivery for test drives, finance options available for the users, free vehicle history reports, seven-day return windows and warranty periods, etc. 

In this article, we are going to talk about the best Carmax alternatives which offer similar features and customer satisfaction to the car enthusiasts with their summaries and pros and cons to watch out for. 

By the end of the article, you will get all the insights into the 6 best CarMax alternatives which are- Carvana, Vroom, Shift, eBay Motors, Craigslist, and Dealerships respectively. 


CarMax Alternatives

Carvana is said to be one of the best CarMax alternatives because it shares a lot of similarities between both. It is the best website for car buying facilities with used vehicles and a great collection to pick from. 

The app promises to offer lower prices with well-maintained used vehicles and also cut down the costs of dealerships commissions and much more. Carvana is a great choice for good deals on cars with friendly prices. 

Caravana is said to have more than 20,000 vehicles to choose from. Carvana also offers 150-point inspections like CarMax and Vroom. They also offer a seven-day money-back guarantee on the vehicles purchased from them. 

Pros of Carvana 

  • You can easily apply for auto loan prequalification via their website. 
  • The vehicles listed on the site are compulsorily scrutinized by 150-point inspection. 
  • Carvana also offers a seven-day return window like CarMax. 
  • The app also has trade-in features to trade your cars. 
  • It offers a limited warranty period of 100 days or 4189 miles. 

Cons of Carvana 

  • The prices are said to be fixed variables, and no bargains or flexibility is observed. 
  • If you want to ship your car at the location, then shipping costs are yours to bear. 
  • The car deliveries are said to be limited and not for all markets. 
  • If opting for Carvana fiances, then co-signers are not accepted. 
Must Try these 24 Sites like Carvana, If you want to Buy/Sell a Car!


Vroom CarMax Alternatives

Vroom is a great and stunning CarMax alternative, which provides financing options, car buying and selling features, and much more. Vroom also offers pore-qualification for loans with soft credit checks and the application procedures are kept online 100%. 

The app is very friendly to the users and is quite easy to navigate. The prices kept by Vrrom have no-haggle prices and it is non-negotiable. Deposits are required on a few cars and vehicles. 

The delivery fees are charged for the delivery of the vehicles at your locations which can go up to $1399. The Vroom still allows free pickups for the purchased vehicles. The listing of cars is done with 360-degree resolution and views to make it real for customers to see and buy. 

Pros of Vroom

  • Vroom offers delivery of the vehicles to your doorstep. 
  • It provides free history reports like Carmax. 
  • Vroom also offers financing options under their title. 
  • Trade-in may be accepted including pickup facilities. 
  • Vroom also offers a 90-day warranty period. 
  • Vroom has kept a 7-day return window open with 250 miles return window too. 

Cons of Vroom 

  • Vroom charges a shipping fee of up to $499 for the deliveries. 
  • The delivery of vehicles may take up time more than 10 days after the purchase order. 
Shift vs Vroom: Is Shift Better than Vroom? [2022]


Shift CarMax Alternatives

The shift is another great Carmax alternative that offers cars in good condition and certified by their speculations. Shift currently runs with more than 75,000 customers with great ratings from Trustpilot and much more. 

The shift is said to have 150 point inspection technique to verify each car before selling and also allows tested rives for the customers to make sure what they are buying and whether they genuinely like the vehicle or not. 

Shift offers free test drives and also offers to schedule the drives to the nearby locations from your home. They also have Shift Concierge who works with you to answer any queries while you are having a test drive. 

Pros of Shift 

  • Prices are kept reasonable. 
  • Trade-ins are accepted. 
  • Customers can apply for online finances via their portal. 
  • Shift offers a 5-day return window or 200 miles return policy option for customers. 

Cons of Shift 

  • Locations are very few. 
  • Prices are fixed, no bargain. 
Shift vs Carvana: Which is Better? [2022]

eBay Motors 

eBay Motors

eBay Motors allows users to buy a vehicle from private sellers with bids and auction techniques. The app offers to buy cars nationwide. The app also provides free protection covered for cars' safety and security. 

eBay Motors is said to be the leading marketplace for to people get connected with sellers and buyers. The app has great deals on cars and vehicles which provide you with genuine products and quick deliveries. 

The app is said to sell parts for cars and motors too. You simply need to create an account with them via email address and phone number to start your journey with eBay Motors. 

Pros of eBay Motors 

  • eBay Motors allows users to purchase vehicles from private sellers nationwide. 
  • eBay Motors also allows protection for buying vehicles under their title. 
  • The app also allows you to apply for finance options with
  • eBay offers new and used vehicles to purchase and select from. 
  • The app also provides the flexibility of winning a bid and not purchasing it. 

Cons of eBay Motors 

  • The app doesn’t provide any return policy. 
  • It doesn’t provide any protection for undisclosed problems. 
  • It doesn’t give any guarantee of you winning the auctions or sales. 


Craigslist car buy car sale

Craigslist is said to be one of the top car selling and buying sites like CarMax, Carvana, etc. It is the most trusted and easy navigation app for cheap deals. If you are looking for pocket-friendly budget prices then Craigslist will never disappoint you. 

The app allows you to buy and sell both. For selling cars, you simply have to write an advertisement with a small description of the vehicles and photos of the same. Set a final price with shipping cost.  Then finally list it down for sales. 

If someone will be interested in your vehicle and pricing then they will contact you via the email address or phone call whichever is available. 

Pros of Craigslist 

  • Craigslist will help you make more money and win bids. 
  • It is a great alternative to buying inexpensive vehicles easily. 
  • The app is very user-friendly and easy for private sales. 

Cons of Craigslist 

  • You will need a lot of research regarding the prices.
  • Selling cars on Craigslist is very tough and not quick and easy. 

Dealerships ( Local Used Cars)

CarMax alternatives

Dealerships are the last resort of CarMax alternatives, it is said to have to buy and sell facilities of used cars in the nearby locality. Dealerships stand for private or franchise car sellers. 

To buy a car or sell a car through Dealerships takes a lot of time, but may benefit you from the nearby locations and locality. Dealerships sound useful if you have to buy or sell used cars in nearby locations. 

Pros of Dealerships 

  • You will get good pickings and bargaining facilities. 
  • Contacting the buyer and seller will be easy. 
  • Any damages or problems can be solved. 
  • It will save your shipping costs and delivery time duration. 

Cons of Dealerships 

  • To get a genuine customer or a great deal is tough. 
  • It takes time to finalize the deal maybe months. 
  • No guarantee to sell your used cars within a few days. 

CarMax Alternatives: Conclusion

Here, we come to an end of the best 6 CarMax Alternatives, CarMax in itself is a great option to buy and sell cars online with all the security checks and safety of vehicles assured. CarMax is a very popular app itself and to compete with the app is a tough call. 

Hence finding the best alternatives for Carmax is a tough task but here we have provided the best apps namely Carvana, Vroom, Shift, eBay Motors, Craigslist, and Dealerships. In this article, you will get all the similarities, pros, and cons of the 6 best Carmax alternatives. 


Which are CarMax Alternatives?

There are 6 best CarMax Alternatives namely-
eBay Motors
Dealership and much more. 

Who owns CarMax?

CarMax is under the hands of Richard L. Sharp.

Who owns Carvana?

Carvana is said to be under the hands of Ernest Garcia III, Ryan Keeton, and Ben Huston. 

Who owns Vroom?

Vroom is managed and ruled by BlackRock Inc. 

Who owns Shift?

Shift car selling and buying sites are owned by George Arison, Toby Russell, Minnie Ingersoll, Christain Ohler, Joel Washington, and Morgan Knutson. 

Who owns eBay Motors?

eBay Motors is owned and managed by eBay Company which is owned by Pierre Omidyar. 

Who owns Craigslist?

Craigslist is under the hands of Craig Newmark.